About Bay Island Siesta Key
Market Summary
Avg. List Price
Current Listings
Avg. Active Days on Market
Currently no active listings available that meet the criteria for market statistics calculations.
What Locals Say
Travelers are here
Sites to see
Nature
Homey & Leisurely
Luxury culture
Dog lovers
Fitness oriented
Hard working
Wine lovers
Hops & brews
market snapshot
We’ve gathered the latest market data to help you better understand what’s happening in Bay Island Siesta Key.
active listings
Currently no active listings available that meet the criteria for market statistics calculations.
Recently Sold
Recently Sold Avg.
Avg. Days on Market
Recently Sold
Avg. Price/Area
Properties in Bay Island Siesta Key
All
Sold
New - 2,601 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
5 bd
7 ba
3200 HIGEL AVENUE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: THE STUTZMAN REALTY GROUP, LLC, Faith Stutzman
Sold
New - 943 Hours
Open House
••
3 bd
3 ba
3721 FLAMINGO AVENUE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: FINE PROPERTIES, 941-782-0000, Sandy McCourtney
Sold
New - 7,528 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
4 bd
6 ba
3550 FLAMINGO AVENUE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY, 941-951-6660, Barbara May
Sold
New - 1,596 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
5 bd
6 ba
3500 BAYOU LOUISE LANE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY, 941-366-8070, Judy Kepecz-Hays
Sold
New - 140 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
3 ba
110 FAUBEL STREET, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY, 941-383-6411, Mairead Smialek
Sold
New - 80 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
4 bd
4 ba
810 SIESTA DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY, 941-364-4000, Liz Arme
Sold
New - 489 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
3 ba
123 FAUBEL STREET, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: RE/MAX PLATINUM REALTY, Adam Kwiat
Sold
New - 111 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
762 SIESTA DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY, 941-364-4000, Steve Wexler
Sold
New - 969 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
684 FREELING DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: KW COASTAL LIVING III, 941-900-4151, Toni Zarghami
Sold
New - 1,866 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
4 bd
5 ba
749 FREELING DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY, 941-364-4000, Judie Berger
Sold
New - 2,308 Hours
Open House
Price Drop
(5d)
View listing to see more images.
••••••
1 bd
1 ba
3460 FLAMINGO AVENUE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY, 941-364-4000, Judie Berger
Sold
New - 2,000 Hours
Open House
Price Drop
(5d)
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3460 FLAMINGO AVENUE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY, 941-364-4000, Judie Berger
Sold
New - 570 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
5 ba
732 SIESTA DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY, 941-349-4411, Jay Mitchell
Sold
New - 3,184 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
4 bd
3 ba
144 GARDEN LANE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY, 941-349-4411, Shane O'Neill
Sold
New - 899 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
4 ba
684 FREELING DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: KW COASTAL LIVING III, 941-900-4151, Toni Zarghami
Sold
New - 2,483 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
3 ba
508 SIESTA DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY, 941-907-9541, Kevin Milner
Sold
New - 442 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
4 ba
684 FREELING DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: KW COASTAL LIVING III, 941-900-4151, Toni Zarghami
Sold
New - 970 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
679 NORSOTA WAY, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY, 941-349-3444, Michael Hays
Sold
New - 1,323 Hours
Open House
Price Drop
(7d)
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
4 ba
3455 ANGLIN DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: NEW DOOR REAL ESTATE LLC, 941-536-9422, Summer McMillan
Sold
New - 993 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3821 FLAMINGO AVENUE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY, 941-349-3444, Michael Hays
Log In / Sign Up
Log in or sign up for a Keller Williams account today and gain access to exclusive content and additional support from a local Keller Williams® agent!
Active
Sold
New - 2,601 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
5 bd
7 ba
3200 HIGEL AVENUE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: THE STUTZMAN REALTY GROUP, LLC, Faith Stutzman
Sold
New - 943 Hours
Open House
••
3 bd
3 ba
3721 FLAMINGO AVENUE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: FINE PROPERTIES, 941-782-0000, Sandy McCourtney
Sold
New - 7,528 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
4 bd
6 ba
3550 FLAMINGO AVENUE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY, 941-951-6660, Barbara May
Sold
New - 1,596 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
5 bd
6 ba
3500 BAYOU LOUISE LANE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY, 941-366-8070, Judy Kepecz-Hays
Sold
New - 140 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
3 ba
110 FAUBEL STREET, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY, 941-383-6411, Mairead Smialek
Sold
New - 80 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
4 bd
4 ba
810 SIESTA DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY, 941-364-4000, Liz Arme
Sold
New - 489 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
3 ba
123 FAUBEL STREET, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: RE/MAX PLATINUM REALTY, Adam Kwiat
Sold
New - 111 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
762 SIESTA DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY, 941-364-4000, Steve Wexler
Sold
New - 969 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
684 FREELING DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: KW COASTAL LIVING III, 941-900-4151, Toni Zarghami
Sold
New - 1,866 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
4 bd
5 ba
749 FREELING DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY, 941-364-4000, Judie Berger
Sold
New - 2,308 Hours
Open House
Price Drop
(5d)
View listing to see more images.
••••••
1 bd
1 ba
3460 FLAMINGO AVENUE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY, 941-364-4000, Judie Berger
Sold
New - 2,000 Hours
Open House
Price Drop
(5d)
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3460 FLAMINGO AVENUE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY, 941-364-4000, Judie Berger
Sold
New - 570 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
5 ba
732 SIESTA DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY, 941-349-4411, Jay Mitchell
Sold
New - 3,184 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
4 bd
3 ba
144 GARDEN LANE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: COLDWELL BANKER REALTY, 941-349-4411, Shane O'Neill
Sold
New - 899 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
4 ba
684 FREELING DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: KW COASTAL LIVING III, 941-900-4151, Toni Zarghami
Sold
New - 2,483 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
3 ba
508 SIESTA DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY, 941-907-9541, Kevin Milner
Sold
New - 442 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
4 ba
684 FREELING DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: KW COASTAL LIVING III, 941-900-4151, Toni Zarghami
Sold
New - 970 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
679 NORSOTA WAY, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY, 941-349-3444, Michael Hays
Sold
New - 993 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3821 FLAMINGO AVENUE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY, 941-349-3444, Michael Hays
Sold
New - 1,024 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
894 FREELING DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: GRECO REAL ESTATE, 941-685-0449, Karen Greco
Log In / Sign Up
Log in or sign up for a Keller Williams account today and gain access to exclusive content and additional support from a local Keller Williams® agent!
Pending
Sold
New - 1,323 Hours
Open House
Price Drop
(7d)
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
4 ba
3455 ANGLIN DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: NEW DOOR REAL ESTATE LLC, 941-536-9422, Summer McMillan
Sold
New - 1,298 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
3 ba
527 FREELING DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY, 941-349-3444, Josie Cline
Sold
New - 3,491 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3441 GULFMEAD DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: RE/MAX ALLIANCE GROUP, 941-954-5454, Tom Cail, PA
Sold
New - 2,651 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
2 bd
2 ba
530 FREELING DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY, 941-951-6660, Barbara May
Sold
New - 1,954 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
530 FREELING DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY, 941-951-6660, Barbara May
Sold
New - 3,039 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
546 FREELING DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY, 941-951-6660, Barbara May
Log In / Sign Up
Log in or sign up for a Keller Williams account today and gain access to exclusive content and additional support from a local Keller Williams® agent!
Upcoming Open Houses
Log In / Sign Up
Log in or sign up for a Keller Williams account today and gain access to exclusive content and additional support from a local Keller Williams® agent!
Recently Sold
Sold
- Mar 17, 2025
New - 1,679 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
4 ba
3532 FLAMINGO AVENUE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: EXIT KING REALTY, 941-497-6060, Ashley Battle
Sold
- Mar 14, 2025
New - 1,509 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
4 bd
4 ba
115 EDMONDSON AVENUE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: LIVING VOGUE LLC, 800-486-1794, Mark Coppens
Sold
- Mar 12, 2025
New - 3,253 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3 bd
2 ba
838 NORSOTA WAY, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: PREFERRED SHORE LLC, 941-999-1179, Roger Clyne
Sold
- Feb 27, 2025
New - 3,349 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
2 bd
2 ba
3210 HIGEL AVENUE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY, 941-951-6660, Jennifer Linehan
Sold
- Jan 29, 2025
New - 3,087 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
864 SIESTA DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: WILLIAM RAVEIS REAL ESTATE, 941-894-1255, Robert Ruiz
Sold
- Jan 29, 2025
New - 3,087 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
4 bd
5 ba
864 SIESTA DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: WILLIAM RAVEIS REAL ESTATE, 941-894-1255, Robert Ruiz
Sold
- Jan 15, 2025
New - 2,989 Hours
Open House
View listing to see more images.
••••••
3460 SEAGRAPE DRIVE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: PREFERRED SHORE LLC, 941-999-1179, Samantha Jennen
Sold
- Jan 2, 2025
New - 3,441 Hours
Open House
••
2 bd
2 ba
141 GARDEN LANE, SARASOTA, FL 34242
Listing Courtesy Of: MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY, 941-951-6660, Nora Johnson
Log In / Sign Up
Log in or sign up for a Keller Williams account today and gain access to exclusive content and additional support from a local Keller Williams® agent!
Nearby Schools
Public
Private
No data to show right now.
N/A
Grade
Student-Teacher Ratio:
No data to show right now.
No data to show right now.
N/A
Grade
Student-Teacher Ratio:
No data to show right now.
Disclaimer: This information is provided by
Precisely
and subject to change.
Please check the applicable school district.
Transit & Commute
Estimated commute times from Bay Island Siesta Key
Car-Dependent
Walkable
Very Walkable
Nearby Neighborhoods
Ringling
41
Current Listings
Strathmore Riverside
20
Current Listings
Rosemary District
49
Current Listings
Phillippi Gardens
5
Current Listings
2nd St/Washington Blvd
24
Current Listings
Hudson Park
7
Current Listings
Downtown
33
Current Listings
Boulevard of the Arts
57
Current Listings
Poms Park
6
Current Listings
Alta Vista
4
Current Listings
Dolphin Bay
12
Current Listings
Gulf & Bay Club
13
Current Listings
Laurel Park
16
Current Listings
Golden Gate Point
41
Current Listings
South Gate
50
Current Listings
Arlington Park
61
Current Listings
Somerset Cove
12
Current Listings
Central Park II
16
Current Listings
Phillippi Creek
71
Current Listings
Siesta Cove/Cape Leyte
41
Current Listings
Palm Island
6
Current Listings
Hudson Bayou
20
Current Listings
Siesta Key Village
38
Current Listings
Bay Point Park
2
Current Listings
The Landings
49
Current Listings
Sandy Hook
1
Current Listings
Sandy Cove
10
Current Listings
Siesta Key
43
Current Listings
ArmaLido
105
Current Listings
South of the Trail
93
Current Listings
Granada
8
Current Listings
Siesta Key North
26
Current Listings